Who Wants to be a Jerk on TV?
About three years ago I was shopping around a short film that I’d made as my senior thesis. It was about super-heroes; a handicap that kept us out of some of the more popular festivals. We tried everywhere, this is just before YouTube, and I end up sending 500 DVD copies of my short all over the country.
It got rejected from more screens than it played on. Oddly enough though, the judges who rejected us passed the DVD on to their friends. It must have been the professional packaging I sprung for but people took the thing seriously in a comedic way, I guess. Occasionally I get e-mails from people telling me they liked it, they gave it to they’re cousin, I should look into such and such a festival… Really encouraging stuff.
Eventually, someone interning at an LA production company tells me about another company they’re working with and that company is developing a property for Mtv about super-heroes. He’s going to get them a copy of my short. We don’t know what the shows’ about but Stan Lee is involved.
Fine, whatever. That’s a year of my life - show anyone who’ll watch.
After a long weekend I get a phone call. It’s a pleasant woman from “Stan Lee’s Super-Hero Project.” Wow. Cool. She tells me they’d like to have the main character from my short, for their series. Amazing. I still don’t know what the shows’ about.
The woman tells me it’s a game show where players compete to have they’re super hero published in a comic book by Stan Lee. We’d be dressed as our creations and live together for up to 16 weeks. During which time we’d have to perform super-heroic feats, like battling super villains.
Super villains?
They planned to pitch the show to Mtv and get some of the standard Mtv celebrities to guest as bad-guys. The nice woman tried to sell me on playing dress up with Carmen Electra and Andy Dick. I’ve always wanted to melt Andy Dick with my laser eyes but I was somewhat underwhelmed and despite having nothing else to fall back on, I politely declined.
Next day she calls back and she’s pretending like I didn’t turn her down already. She’s making plans to send me paper work and she wants to know if I still have the costume from the short. I’m expected to make an audition tape for the DVD casting special they plan to produce. I remind her that I’m not interested. She reminds me about Andy Dick.
There’s a valley between us.
She keeps telling me I’m going to regret this, it’s a missed opportunity. I should just put on the costume and make the audition tape. Just put on the costume and take some pictures of myself. I mention I didn’t even star in the short, it was some other guy. She doesn’t care, nobody cares, they need warm bodies.
It’s at this point she loses the pleasant twinge to her voice and she turned into someone’s mom. She scolded me for every other aspiring comic creator who turned her down. It was beyond her to reason why we were passing at this golden opportunity. She had confused us with the attention whores who’ll debase themselves to get on television.
I tell her straight, I know they’re going to misrepresent me. They have an agenda and I think it’s crummy. They prey on people who don’t know the difference between reality game show contestant, television actor and porn star.* Not in the pursuit of better television (as if such a thing as good television were even a regular occurrence) but to reinforce stereotypes about comic book fans that don’t even exist anymore. Comic book movies make bank, you’re making a super-hero television show, comic books are popular… Sort of.
We parted ways. It’s that easy to not wind up an idiot on national television.
I’m pretty sure that show ended up as Sci-Fi’s terrible Who Wants To Be A Super Hero?. And though I don’t regret passing on the chance to be made a fool of, I’ll always wonder what might have been had Andy Dick and I met on the field of combat.
*Actual order of their importance.
















Clearly you never watched America’s Next Top So you Think You Can Superhero: Tiki God Island Volume 39 Big Brother edition. The show is amazing.
August 17th, 2007 at 2:16 pm
XD
I’d be a pornstar before I’d be a reality show contestant! XD
*pose*
XD
ALSO
Good for you for turning it down! And yus, from what I know of the show it seems to reinforce stereotypes. :\
August 18th, 2007 at 12:10 am
You know what? I posted a comment (since deleted) politely defending Who Want’s To Be A Super Hero? because I enjoy it. But you know what? F**k it… It’s just a TV show.
August 18th, 2007 at 8:01 am
SwineBread, I’ve read your posts and I got an e-mail notification with the comment you deleted.
You make great points, looks like harmless fun. But television is a powerful medium and a show with “family” appeal is crossing the age gaps. No matter how subtly they reinforce stereo types it’s still making it ok to accept sterotypes in general.
This is why unscripted storytelling (I don’t mean improve I mean reality tv)doesn’t work. At it’s base every story is a morality story and reality tv has no moral - its just the worst parts of people on display like a car wreck that appeals to the least common denominator of our thought process.
It’s a problem I have with the “genre” not the show, per say.
That’s my closest experience with reality TV although I’ve had friends in similar circumstances on different shows.
August 18th, 2007 at 10:30 am
The moral vacuum of Reality TV is of course a very valid criticism of the genre. I like WWTBAS for at least mentioning issues of integrity and honesty. But, yes it can be played and manipulated with by the producers. Maybe we just need some good dramas about the comic book world like American Splendor.
You might be interested in Series 7: The Contenders everything about reality TV that’s presented in it has come to pass in this made for TV movie… except the murdering people part. I’m sure that’s coming though.
August 20th, 2007 at 12:06 pm